Press Release
5th July 2004

Meeting with NHS Expert “Positive and Productive”
Greenock and Inverclyde’s MP and MSP, David Cairns and Duncan McNeil, have described as “positive and productive” their meeting with Duncan McNeil MSP and David Cairns MP meeting with Dr Andrew Walker Glasgow University’s Dr Andrew Walker – the leading Health Economist charged with carrying out the independent evaluation of NHS Argyll and Clyde's clinical strategy.

Speaking after the hour-long meeting, which took place at the Greenock and Inverclyde Parliamentary Office in Union Street, Mr McNeil said:

“It is not surprising that, in light of our recent experiences, our community is sceptical about so-called ‘consultation’ exercises in the NHS.  But Dr Walker certainly seems to be interested in what we have to say and determined to scrutinise this plan closely.

“We set out our concerns over the impact this plan would have on patient care and the local economy.  We also made it clear that the lack of detail in the document was unacceptable, as was its publication on a ‘take it or leave it’ basis.

“I look forward to continuing these discussions with Dr Walker in the coming weeks and months.”

Mr Cairns added:

“I am delighted that Dr Walker took the time to come along and hear what we had to say.  We are the first people he has spoken to about the Health Board's plans, and I told him in that I am deeply concerned about the flaws in NHS Argyll and Clyde's Clinical Strategy.

“There is a tremendous amount of cynicism about the consultation process within Inverclyde, and Dr Walker will have to convince local people that this will be a genuine consultation and that their view will be given full consideration, not just dismissed out of hand.

“He seemed to listen carefully to what we had to say and took on board the points we raised.  I understand the problems faced by our hospitals in Inverclyde, but the Health Board must show that they are willing to listen to what local people have to say and not press ahead with centralisation of services in Paisley just because it's the easiest option.” 
ENDS

Back to Current Press Releases  

[ HOME ] [ News ] [ Report to the People ] [ Interact ] [ Links ] [ E-Mail ]

[ Copyright ] [ Directgov ] [ Scottish Parliament ]

Previous Page